The Coffin of Andy and Leyley

Top 5 Online Horror Games

👻 Top 5 Online Horror Games That Will Keep You Up at Night

If you’re afraid of the dark — step in. If you’re not — this list will remind you that fear is always nearby.

💀 Introduction

Indie horror games have taken over the genre. They don’t compete in graphics or budgets — they hit you straight in the nervous system. These games are terrifying not because of jumpscares, but because they make you think, sit alone with your anxiety, or even face your own moral discomfort.

Below are 5 online horror games, each unique in its own way. They’re nothing alike, yet they all explore fear — and every one of them has become a phenomenon.

1. Backrooms — a digital nightmare you can’t escape

📌 Concept: A community-born creepypasta adapted into dozens of versions by different developers (most popular: Pie On A Plate Productions)

What it is:
Backrooms is no longer a single game — it’s a horror genre of its own. It all began with an eerie photo of a yellow-lit office hallway and a caption about “noclipping out of reality” and falling into a liminal void.

Gameplay:
Most versions drop the player into endless identical rooms with buzzing fluorescent lights, pale yellow walls, and the constant sense of being watched. The goal is to find a way out — while avoiding the “entities” that may or may not be there.

What makes it scary:
Backrooms is terrifying because it taps into the unexplainable. The environment itself becomes the enemy. This is horror rooted in silence, emptiness, and the fear of being forgotten.

2. Hungry Lamu — a llama you can’t run from

📌 Developer: Kulu

What it is:
On the surface, this game looks like a cute cartoon adventure. You play as a smiling llama picking fruit and interacting with «fruit friends.» Visually, it resembles a preschool show.

Gameplay:
What starts as a light 2D adventure quickly turns dark. You soon discover the “fruit friends” are people in costume. Then the game shifts into a pixelated 3D horror mode, and now you’re no longer the llama — you’re running from it.

What makes it scary:
The contrast. The cheery intro builds trust, only to shatter it moments later. The visual betrayal is jarring — and that’s exactly what makes it stick with you.

3. Baldi’s Basics New School Remastered — where mistakes can be deadly

📌 Original: Mystman12 | Remaster: Basically Games & modding community

What it is:
A fan-made remaster of the cult classic Baldi’s Basics in Education and Learning. What began as a parody of ’90s edutainment games became a surreal horror experience.

Gameplay:
Solve math problems, collect notebooks, and avoid the wrath of Baldi. The remaster adds more levels, mechanics, and layers of absurd horror. Each mistake brings you one step closer to Baldi — and one step deeper into the chaos.

What makes it scary:
Everything feels «almost normal» — and that’s what makes it unsettling. The visuals mimic old school software, but the experience is pure nightmare fuel. It’s not just a game — it’s a glitch in reality.

4. Buckshot Roulette — pressure, risk, and a 12-gauge shotgun

📌 Developer: Mike Klubnika (Estonia)

What it is:
A tabletop indie horror where cards are replaced by a shotgun and every choice could be your last. The gritty, industrial aesthetic is paired with an original soundtrack written by the developer himself.

Gameplay:
Face off against the mysterious Dealer in three rounds of deadly chance. Load the shotgun with a mix of live and blank shells, and choose whether to shoot yourself or your opponent. Use items to strategize, bluff, and survive. In Double or Nothing mode, risk everything for higher rewards — or lose it all.

What makes it scary:
It’s all tension. No monsters. No jumpscares. Just the dread of decision-making under pressure. This is psychological horror at its best — and it works.

5. The Coffin of Andy and Leyley — a grim tale you can’t look away from

📌 Developer: Nemlei | Publisher: Kit9 Studio

What it is:
A psychological visual novel and adventure game about two morally irredeemable siblings. It’s a story of codependency, betrayal, ritual, and madness. Currently in early access, with 2 of 4 planned episodes released.

Gameplay:
You play as brother and sister, making disturbing choices that branch into multiple harsh outcomes. The gameplay blends exploration, decision-making, and unsettling narrative, all wrapped in expressive hand-drawn visuals and haunting music.

What makes it scary:
This game isn’t for the faint of heart. It doesn’t rely on gore — it challenges you with moral rot, manipulation, and helplessness. And yet, it’s hypnotic. The art style, the tone, and the atmosphere pull you in — and don’t let go.

🧠 Conclusion: Where does true fear hide?

Horror is no longer one-dimensional. Today, it can be absurd, philosophical, surreal — even darkly comedic. What matters is that it makes you feel something. And these five games absolutely do:

Horror doesn’t scream anymore — it whispers.
And that’s what makes it so much scarier.